A great pie requires not only a good recipe but also a high-quality pie dish. The right pie dish can help you bake a delicious pie in no time, and produce perfect wedges. To help you choose the most reliable pie dish, we’ve selected the top-rated pie dishes available in the market.
So, what is the best pie dish to use? We recommend looking for glass or aluminum pie dishes. Aluminum-made pie dishes are known for producing superior crusts, as they puff up the dough lightly. Additionally, they are easy to transport and perfect for picnics.
In this review, we have researched and tested various pie dishes to provide you with accurate and reliable information. Our list includes pie dishes that come in different sizes and materials to meet various needs and preferences. Whether you’re looking for a deep-dish pie plate or a classic round pie dish, we’ve got you covered.
Choosing the right pie dish is an essential step to making a delicious and beautiful pie. We hope that our review will help you find the best pie dish for your needs, and make your next baking experience a success.
A List of Top 10 Best Pie Dishes
Browse our content
PYREX EASY GRAB PIE PLATE
Made in the USA, the pie plate is best for most recipes. Also, this pie plate comes with easy grab rims to increase the grip. Away from that, this pie plate features elegant and straightforward white pieces. It’s made with high-quality tempered glass. Moreover, the glass will not absorb food odors.
Pros
- Easy to grab rims
- Elegant and simple white pieces
- High quality tempered glass
Cons
- Expensive
MRS ANDERSON’S BAKING PIE
This baking pie is known for blind baking without making the pies shrink. Also, it has been made from natural and food-safe stoneware. The stone-ware can work at 480 degrees. The manufacturer has included a convenient storage container. Besides that, the individual beads are easy to place. You will have an easy time arranging them. It is a durable pie dish that will serve you for years.
Pros
- This pie dish does not shrink pies
- Food safe stoneware
- Convenient storage container
Cons
- Pies will stick to this pie dish
PYREX EASY GRAB PIE DISH
It is among the few pie dishes that have been made with large handles. Away from that, it features a glass lid that makes this pie dish a kitchen essential. Made with high-quality tempered glass, it will not absorb food odors. Finally, it comes with many features that will improve your overall baking experience.
Pros
- It has been manufactured from high-quality material
- It does not absorb food odors
- Large handles
Cons
- You need to clean it thoroughly after baking
MRS ANDERSON’S 10-INCH PIE PLATES
Have you been looking for an elegant pie plate that allows your pies to rise while reducing spillage? This pie plate will prevent pie crusts from burning. It is made from aluminum material. It is good to know that aluminum material is strong and durable. Moreover, you will have an easy time when baking your pies.
Pros
- Reduces spillage
- Aluminum material
- Easy to use
Cons
- Expensive pie plate
MONTOPACK ALUMINUM PIE PLATE
They’re made of heavy-duty and durable aluminum material. Also, the small pie dishes will not bend during baking. These pie plates are easy to clean. You don’t have to worry after every baking session. Moreover, these pie plates can be used in camping and travel. Finally, they are the perfect choice for stack and store.
Pros
- Perfect for stack and store
- Durable aluminum material
- Best for camping
Cons
- They can only be used twice
USA PAN STEEL PIE
The pan steel pie has been manufactured by a popular pie dishes manufacturing company from the United States of America. Besides that, it is a commercial grade and heavy gauge pie dish. Away from that, the corrugated surface design increases air circulation. This ensures evenly baked goods. Moreover, it is a BPA free pie plate. It has been made with recycled steel.
Pros
- High-quality steel
- BPA Free
Cons
- It is costly when compared to most pie dishes models
EMILE HENRY MADE PIE DISH
The manufacturer has been making high-quality pie dishes since 1850. This pie dish uses all-natural materials. Also, it comes with high superior heat retention. Besides the even heat diffusion features, this pie dish is resistant against temperature changes. Moreover, it is a durable pie that does not scratch when baking.
Pros
- It does not scratch when baking
- Durable
- Superior heat retention
Cons
- It is not large enough to bake large cakes.
CAST IRON PIE PAN
This is the right time to bake your pies to perfection using cast iron pie pan. The manufacturer has made this pie pan with decorative handles for added convenience. Besides that, the handles have been made with high-quality iron material. This increase handles durability. The pie will not stick to the pie plate.
Pros
- Pie does not stick to the pie plate
- It is made of high-quality iron
Cons
- The cast iron collection can’t be compared to top pie pans in the market
G AND S METAL PIE PANS
The package comes with two large pans to bake sizeable pies. It features a non-stick finish that helps your pie to release easily. High-quality steel build increases the pie durability. This ensures heating across the pan. The pie dish is made in the United States of America.
Pros
- Quality steel construction
- The pie will not stick to this pie dish
Cons
- The diameter of the pie dish is less than 10 inches
FAT DADDIO’S ALUMINUM
This pie dish is best for professional baking. Also, it comes with a flat rom design that measures about 5 inches. Away from that, it is deeper than the traditional pie dish. The anodized aluminum provides the ideal baking surface. Made with a non-reactive finish, it is a reliable pie dish.
Pros
- Aluminum provides an ideal baking surface
- Durable and non-reactive finish
Cons
- The shape is not like the normal pie dish